| New York Red Bulls - Andres Reyes | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Julian Aude | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Sean Nealis | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Cory Burke | 10/1 | 7/2 | 10/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Diego Fagundez | 11/1 | 4/1 | 11/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Cameron Harper | 14/1 | 5/1 | 14/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Serge Ngoma | 18/1 | 13/2 | 18/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Mauricio Cuevas | 22/1 | 8/1 | 22/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Edwin Cerrillo | 28/1 | 11/1 | 28/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Chaves Gabriel Pec | 9/2 | 3/2 | 9/2 |
| LA Galaxy - Marco Reus | 8/1 | 11/4 | 8/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Aidan O'connor | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| LA Galaxy - John Nelson | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Noah Eile | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Emil Forsberg | 9/1 | 33/10 | 9/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Dante Vanzeir | 11/1 | 4/1 | 11/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Julian Hall | 14/1 | 5/1 | 14/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Dennis Gjengaar | 18/1 | 13/2 | 18/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Marky Delgado | 20/1 | 15/2 | 20/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Carlos Garces | 28/1 | 11/1 | 28/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Lewis Morgan | 15/2 | 13/5 | 15/2 |
| New York Red Bulls - Peter Stroud | 33/1 | 12/1 | 33/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Dylan Nealis | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Miki Yamane | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Ruben Ramos | 8/1 | 11/4 | 8/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - De Paula Elias Manoel | 10/1 | 7/2 | 10/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Isaiah Parente | 14/1 | 5/1 | 14/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Wikelman Carmona | 14/1 | 5/1 | 14/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Felipe Carballo | 20/1 | 15/2 | 20/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Maya Yoshida | 25/1 | 9/1 | 25/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Joseph Paintsil | 13/2 | 9/4 | 13/2 |
| New York Red Bulls - John Tolkin | 28/1 | 11/1 | 28/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Daniel Edelman | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Kyle Duncan | 40/1 | 16/1 | 40/1 |
| No Goalscorer | 14/1 | 14/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Roald Mitchell | 10/1 | 7/2 | 10/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Mohammed Sofo | 12/1 | 9/2 | 12/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Gaston Brugman | 16/1 | 6/1 | 16/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Eriq Zavaleta | 20/1 | 15/2 | 20/1 |
| New York Red Bulls - Ronald Donkor | 22/1 | 8/1 | 22/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Jalen Neal | 28/1 | 11/1 | 28/1 |
| LA Galaxy - Dejan Joveljic | 9/2 | 3/2 | 9/2 |
| LA Galaxy - Miguel Berry | 8/1 | 11/4 | 8/1 |
